The Parts of an Argument

An argument has three parts: a claim, a reason and evidence. Remove the evidence and you have a belief. Remove the reason and you have a slogan.

Most disagreements that go nowhere are disagreements about different parts without anyone saying so. One person disputes the evidence, the other defends the claim, and both leave convinced the other was not listening.

So before arguing, locate the disagreement. Do you doubt that the thing is true, or do you accept it and doubt that it matters? These need different responses, and answering the wrong one is why an argument can go around three times with no movement.

Naming the point of disagreement out loud is not a concession. It is the only way the conversation can go anywhere.

This week's exercise

Take a disagreement you have had. Identify which part was actually in dispute, and write five sentences on it.

Vocabulary

Tap to flipclaim
the statement being argued for
Tap to flipevidence
facts supporting a claim
Tap to flipslogan
a memorable phrase without reasoning
Tap to flipdispute
to question or challenge
Tap to flipconcession
admitting a point to the other side

Quick check

What do you have without evidence?

Why do many disagreements go nowhere?

© 2026 Bemnat Academy. All rights reserved.